Stokes Picks vs Pixotine and Smart Toothpicks
November 17, 2026 · Hayden Dudley
Stokes, Pixotine and Smart Toothpicks all make birch toothpicks with nicotine in the wood. The main differences are strength (5 mg per pick for Stokes, about 3 mg for the other two), the number of picks in a pack, the flavors, the ingredients each brand lists and the price per pick.
We make Stokes, so we are one of the three brands on this page. To keep the comparison fair, everything we say about Pixotine and Smart Toothpicks comes from their own websites as of November 2026, with a link so you can check it. Where a site does not state something, we say "not listed". We are not going to tell you which one to buy.
This page is for adults 21 and over who already use nicotine. If you do not use nicotine, do not start.
How do the three brands compare side by side?
| Stokes | Pixotine | Smart Toothpicks | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nicotine per pick | 5 mg | About 3 mg | 3 mg |
| Picks per pack | 16 | About 15 | 20, individually wrapped |
| Flavors | Vanilla Mint, Lemon Ginger, Cinnamon Clove, Absinthe | Winter Ice, Cinnamon, Original, Tobacco | Cinnamon, Wintergreen, Peppermint Ice |
| Wood | American white birch | Birch | Birch |
| Ingredients listed | Birch, nicotine, certified organic flavors, organic monk fruit, vegetable glycerin | Nicotine, vegetable glycerin, natural and artificial flavors | Not listed |
| Sweetener | Organic monk fruit | None in its ingredient list | Not listed. Site says 0 sugar |
| How long a pick lasts, per the brand | 20 to 60 minutes | 15 minutes to 1 hour | Not listed |
| Single pack price | $7 | $6.99 | $6.99 |
| Price per pick, single pack | About 44 cents | About 47 cents | About 35 cents |
Sources for the table: the Pixotine product page and collection page, and the Smart Toothpicks product page, nicotine category and home page. Pixotine writes "~ 3.0 mg" and "approx. 15", so we wrote "about".
Which one has the most nicotine per pick?
Stokes does. Every Stokes pick has 5 mg, in all four flavors. Pixotine lists about 3 mg per pick. Smart Toothpicks lists 3 mg.
More is not better. It is just more. If you want less nicotine per pick, Pixotine and Smart Toothpicks both list less than Stokes, and Stokes does not make a lower strength. If 5 mg is what you are looking for, that is the Stokes pick.
The milligram number is the nicotine in the pick. It is not a measure of how a pick will feel to you. Whichever brand you try, start with one pick and wait before you take another. There is more on this in how much nicotine is in a nicotine toothpick.
How many picks do you get in a pack?
- Smart Toothpicks: 20 per packet, and each pick is wrapped on its own.
- Stokes: 16 in a flat resealable pack.
- Pixotine: about 15 per pack. Its site describes the pack as sized to fit pockets and wallets.
Individual wrapping matters to some people. If you carry a few loose picks in a pocket or bag, Smart Toothpicks is the only one of the three that lists it.
What flavors does each brand make?
Pixotine and Smart Toothpicks both stay close to classic toothpick flavors. Pixotine makes Winter Ice, Cinnamon, Original and Tobacco. Its site describes Winter Ice as a flavor for wintergreen, mint and menthol fans. Smart Toothpicks makes Cinnamon, Wintergreen and Peppermint Ice.
Stokes makes Vanilla Mint, Lemon Ginger, Cinnamon Clove and Absinthe. Absinthe tastes like black licorice and has no alcohol in it.
All three make a cinnamon and a mint of some kind. If you want wintergreen or a tobacco flavor, look at the other two brands, because Stokes does not make either. If you want citrus or a herbal flavor, Stokes is the only one of the three that lists one.
What is in each pick?
This is where the three sites differ most in how much they tell you.
Pixotine lists three ingredients on its product page: nicotine, vegetable glycerin, and natural and artificial flavors. It describes the nicotine as USP grade nicotine extract and the wood as birch. No sweetener appears in the list.
Smart Toothpicks does not list ingredients on the product pages we read. Its site says the picks have 0 calories and 0 sugar, and its home page says its toothpicks are birch. We could not find a statement about which sweetener it uses, if any, so we have left that as "not listed". If it matters to you, ask the brand.
Stokes lists five ingredients: American white birch, tobacco-free nicotine, certified organic flavors, organic monk fruit and vegetable glycerin. There is no sugar, no sucralose and no artificial flavor. The ingredient guide explains what each one does.
A different ingredient list does not make one pick better for you than another, and we are not claiming that. The choice here is about what you prefer. If you want organic flavors and monk fruit, that is Stokes. If you do not want any sweetener in the list at all, Pixotine's list has none.
What does each one cost per pick?
Single packs cost almost the same, but the packs hold different numbers of picks. We divided the listed price by the listed count and rounded to the nearest cent. These sums are ours, and they leave out shipping and tax. For the Smart Toothpicks multi-packs we assumed 20 picks in each packet, as its single packet lists.
| Single pack | Larger sizes listed | |
|---|---|---|
| Stokes | $7 for 16, about 44 cents a pick | 6-pack $30, about 31 cents. 12-pack $48, 25 cents. 48-pack bundle $168, about 22 cents |
| Pixotine | $6.99 for about 15, about 47 cents a pick | Carton of 15 packs $69.99, about 31 cents |
| Smart Toothpicks | $6.99 for 20, about 35 cents a pick | 3 pack $19.00 and 6 pack $38.00, about 32 cents. 18 pack $90.00, 25 cents |
On a single pack, Smart Toothpicks costs the least per pick. Stokes and Pixotine are within a few cents of each other. In bulk, all three come down to somewhere between 22 and 32 cents a pick.
Two things to keep in mind. A Stokes pick has more nicotine than the other two, so you are not comparing identical products. And shipping changes the total. Stokes charges a flat $10 and ships free on orders over $48. Pixotine and Smart Toothpicks set their own shipping, so check the cart on each site.
Do you use them the same way?
Mostly, but not exactly. Each brand gives its own directions, and you should follow the ones for the brand you buy.
Stokes says to hold the pick between your cheek and gum and not to chew it, because wood can splinter. Most people keep a Stokes pick in for 20 to 60 minutes and flip to the unused end when the flavor fades. Our guide on how long a nicotine toothpick lasts has more detail.
Pixotine's product page says a pick can last from 15 minutes to up to an hour, and that chewing slightly speeds up the release. It also warns not to use more than one toothpick at a time. Smart Toothpicks does not give a time on the pages we read.
Where can you buy each one?
Stokes sells from this site to adults 21 and over and ships to all 50 states and Washington, D.C. Some states require an adult signature at delivery.
Pixotine sells from its own site and says sale is only allowed in the United States. It also has a store finder, so you may be able to buy it in person. Smart Toothpicks sells from its own site. It does not list where it ships on the pages we read.
Which one might suit you?
- Smart Toothpicks may suit you if you want 3 mg, individually wrapped picks, wintergreen, or the lowest single-pack price per pick of the three.
- Pixotine may suit you if you want about 3 mg, a tobacco or original flavor, a short ingredient list with no sweetener in it, or a brand you can look for in stores.
- Stokes may suit you if you want 5 mg per pick, certified organic flavors, monk fruit as the only sweetener, or flavors like Lemon Ginger and Absinthe.
If you are still unsure, a single pack from each brand costs about $7. For a wider view that also covers Z-Pix, see our nicotine toothpick brand comparison.
What do all three have in common?
All three contain nicotine. The FDA says nicotine is a highly addictive chemical that keeps people using tobacco products even when they want to stop. That applies to a 3 mg pick and a 5 mg pick alike.
None of them is a medicine. Nicotine toothpicks are not approved to help anyone quit smoking or vaping, and Stokes does not sell its picks for that. There are no long-term studies on nicotine toothpicks from any brand.
Do not use any of them if you are under 21, pregnant or nursing, or if you do not already use nicotine. If you have a heart condition or take prescription medication, talk to your doctor first. If you have gum problems, ask your dentist. Keep the picks away from children and pets.
If Stokes sounds like the fit, the Variety Bundle has one pack of each flavor.
Sources
WARNING: This product contains nicotine. Nicotine is an addictive chemical. For adults 21+ only. Stokes does not diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.