# Best Nicotine Toothpicks: An Honest Brand Comparison

> Four nicotine toothpick brands compared by strength, picks per pack, flavors, ingredients and price per pick, using numbers from each brand's own site.

- Source: https://stokespicks.com/insights/best-nicotine-toothpicks
- Author: Hayden Dudley
- Published: 2026-11-17

There is no single best nicotine toothpick. The right one for you depends on how much nicotine you want per pick, which flavors you like, which ingredients you want or want to avoid, and what you want to pay per pick.

Before you read further, you should know that Stokes makes one of the brands in this comparison. We wrote this page, so treat it the way you would treat any brand talking about its competitors. To keep it fair, every number about another brand comes from that brand's own website, and we link to the page so you can check it. We do not name a winner.

This guide is for adults 21 and over who already use nicotine. If you do not use nicotine, the best nicotine toothpick is none.

## How did we compare the brands?

We looked at six names people search for: Pixotine, Smart Toothpicks, Crave, NicPicks, Zippix and Stokes.

- We used only what each brand states on its own website, as of November 2026.
- Where a site does not state something, the table says "not listed". We did not fill gaps from stores, reviews or memory.
- Zippix now sells under the name [Z-Pix](https://zpixtoothpicks.com/pages/faqs), so that is the name we use below.
- We could not find a brand-run website for Crave or NicPicks that lists these numbers, so we left both out instead of guessing.

Prices and products change. Check each brand's site before you buy.

## How do the brands compare side by side?

| Brand | Nicotine per pick | Picks per pack | Flavors | Wood | Price per pack on its own site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| [Pixotine](https://pixotine.com/products/pixotine-winter-ice-15-nicotine-toothpicks) | About 3 mg | About 15 | Winter Ice, Cinnamon, Original, Tobacco | Birch | $6.99 |
| [Smart Toothpicks](https://www.smarttoothpicks.com/product/cinnamon-necotine-toothpick/) | 3 mg | 20, individually wrapped | Cinnamon, Wintergreen, Peppermint Ice | Birch | $6.99 |
| [Z-Pix](https://zpixtoothpicks.com/products/zippix-20-count-packs) (formerly Zippix) | 2 mg or 3 mg, by flavor | 20 or 100 | Mocha, Peppermint Watermelon, Cinnamon, Spice Island Clove, Sweet Whisky, Sweet Wood | Wood, type not listed | $7.99 for 20, $23.99 for 100 |
| [Stokes](https://stokespicks.com/shop) | 5 mg | 16 | Vanilla Mint, Lemon Ginger, Cinnamon Clove, Absinthe | American white birch | $7 |

A few notes on the table. Pixotine's site says "approx." for its count and "~" for its strength, so we wrote "about". Z-Pix lists Sweet Whisky and Sweet Wood at 3 mg and its other four flavors at 2 mg.

## How do you choose by strength?

Strength is the clearest difference between these brands. It runs from 2 mg to 5 mg per pick.

- **2 mg:** Z-Pix in Mocha, Peppermint Watermelon, Cinnamon and Spice Island Clove.
- **3 mg:** Pixotine, Smart Toothpicks, and Z-Pix in Sweet Whisky and Sweet Wood.
- **5 mg:** Stokes, in every flavor.

If you prefer a lower amount of nicotine per pick, Z-Pix, Pixotine and Smart Toothpicks all list less than Stokes does. Stokes makes only one strength. If 5 mg is more than you want, one of the other brands may suit you better.

The number on the pack is the nicotine in the pick. It is not a promise of how a pick will feel to you. With any brand, start with one pick and wait before you take another. Our guide on [how much nicotine is in a nicotine toothpick](https://stokespicks.com/insights/how-much-nicotine-is-in-a-nicotine-toothpick) goes deeper.

## How do you choose by flavor?

This one is personal, so here is simply what each brand makes.

- **Mint and wintergreen:** Pixotine Winter Ice, Smart Toothpicks Wintergreen and Peppermint Ice, Z-Pix Peppermint Watermelon, Stokes Vanilla Mint.
- **Cinnamon:** all four brands make one. Stokes pairs it with clove. Z-Pix also has a separate clove flavor.
- **Coffee and spirits:** Z-Pix Mocha and Sweet Whisky.
- **Tobacco and original:** Pixotine makes a Tobacco flavor and an Original flavor.
- **Citrus and herbal:** Stokes Lemon Ginger and Absinthe. Absinthe tastes like black licorice and has no alcohol in it.

Z-Pix has the most flavors, with six. Smart Toothpicks has three. Pixotine and Stokes have four each.

## How do you choose by ingredients?

Brands share different amounts of detail here. This is what each site lists.

- **Pixotine** lists [nicotine, vegetable glycerin, and natural and artificial flavors](https://pixotine.com/products/pixotine-winter-ice-15-nicotine-toothpicks). No sweetener appears in its list.
- **Z-Pix** lists [glycerine, sucralose, sodium citrate, potassium sorbate, nicotine and flavors](https://zpixtoothpicks.com/products/zippix-20-count-packs). Its site says the nicotine is plant derived.
- **Smart Toothpicks** does not list ingredients on the product pages we read. It does say its picks have [0 calories and 0 sugar](https://www.smarttoothpicks.com/product/cinnamon-necotine-toothpick/).
- **Stokes** lists five ingredients: American white birch, tobacco-free nicotine, certified organic flavors, organic monk fruit and vegetable glycerin. There is no sugar and no sucralose. The [ingredient guide](https://stokespicks.com/insights/stokes-picks-ingredient-list) explains each one.

None of this makes one pick better for you than another. It is a matter of preference. Some people want a short list. Some avoid a certain sweetener, and some do not mind it. If a brand does not list something you care about, ask the brand before you buy.

## How do you choose by price per pick?

Pack prices look close, but packs hold different numbers of picks. Dividing the price by the count gives a fairer number. These are our own sums from the listed prices, rounded to the nearest cent, before shipping and tax.

| Brand | Single pack | Largest size we found listed |
|---|---|---|
| Pixotine | $6.99 for about 15, about 47 cents a pick | Carton of 15 packs for $69.99, about 31 cents a pick |
| Smart Toothpicks | $6.99 for 20, about 35 cents a pick | 18 pack for $90.00, 25 cents a pick |
| Z-Pix | $7.99 for 20, about 40 cents a pick | 100 count for $23.99, about 24 cents a pick |
| Stokes | $7 for 16, about 44 cents a pick | 48-pack bundle for $168, about 22 cents a pick |

On a single pack, Smart Toothpicks has the lowest price per pick and Pixotine and Stokes have the highest. At larger sizes the four brands land within about 10 cents of each other. Z-Pix gets to a low price with the smallest order, since its 100-count pack is $23.99.

Remember that the picks are not the same strength. A 2 mg pick and a 5 mg pick are different products, so price per pick is only part of the picture. Shipping also changes the total. Stokes charges a flat $10 and ships free on orders over $48.

## Where does each brand ship?

- **Stokes** ships to all 50 states and Washington, D.C. Some states require an adult signature at delivery. Stokes does not ship outside the United States or to APO, FPO and DPO addresses. See our [state shipping page](https://stokespicks.com/legal/state-shipping-restrictions).
- **Pixotine** says on its site that [sale is only allowed in the United States](https://pixotine.com/collections/nicotine-toothpicks). It also has a store finder if you would rather buy in person.
- **Z-Pix** says it [ships throughout the U.S.](https://zpixtoothpicks.com/pages/faqs)
- **Smart Toothpicks** does not list its shipping destinations on the pages we read. Its site says shipping cost is worked out when you order.

Rules for nicotine products differ by state and city. Every brand may have places it cannot deliver to, so check at checkout.

## Which brand might suit which buyer?

Here is a fair way to read the numbers above.

- **You want the lowest nicotine per pick.** Look at the 2 mg Z-Pix flavors.
- **You want a 3 mg pick in classic mint or cinnamon.** Pixotine and Smart Toothpicks both make one. Z-Pix makes two 3 mg flavors of its own.
- **You want each pick wrapped on its own.** Smart Toothpicks lists its picks as individually wrapped.
- **You want the most flavors or a 100-count pack.** Z-Pix has six flavors and sells in packs of 100.
- **You want a tobacco flavor.** Pixotine makes one.
- **You want to buy in a store.** Pixotine has a store finder on its site.
- **You want 5 mg per pick, organic flavors, and monk fruit as the only sweetener.** That is what [Stokes](https://stokespicks.com/shop) makes.

If two brands both fit, a single pack of each costs about $7 to $8. Trying one of each is a reasonable way to decide.

## What is the same about every brand?

Every pick on this page contains nicotine. The FDA says [nicotine is a highly addictive chemical](https://www.fda.gov/tobacco-products/health-effects-tobacco-use/nicotine-why-tobacco-products-are-addictive) that keeps people using tobacco products even when they want to stop. That is true at 2 mg and at 5 mg, and it is true of our picks as much as anyone else's.

Nicotine toothpicks are not approved to help anyone quit smoking or vaping. Stokes does not sell its picks for that. There are also no long-term studies on nicotine toothpicks from any brand. We cover what is known and what is not in [Are nicotine toothpicks safe?](https://stokespicks.com/insights/are-nicotine-toothpicks-safe).

Do not use any of these if you are under 21, pregnant or nursing, or if you do not already use nicotine. If you have a heart condition or take prescription medication, talk to your doctor first. Keep every brand's picks away from children and pets.

For a closer look at three of these brands, read [Stokes Picks vs Pixotine and Smart Toothpicks](https://stokespicks.com/insights/stokes-picks-vs-pixotine-smart-toothpicks).

## Sources

- [Pixotine: Winter Ice (15 Nicotine Toothpicks) product page](https://pixotine.com/products/pixotine-winter-ice-15-nicotine-toothpicks)
- [Pixotine: Nicotine Toothpicks collection](https://pixotine.com/collections/nicotine-toothpicks)
- [Smart Toothpicks: Cinnamon Nicotine Toothpick product page](https://www.smarttoothpicks.com/product/cinnamon-necotine-toothpick/)
- [Smart Toothpicks: Nicotine product category](https://www.smarttoothpicks.com/product-category/necotine/)
- [Z-Pix: 20 Count Packs product page](https://zpixtoothpicks.com/products/zippix-20-count-packs)
- [Z-Pix: FAQs](https://zpixtoothpicks.com/pages/faqs)
- [FDA: Nicotine Is Why Tobacco Products Are Addictive](https://www.fda.gov/tobacco-products/health-effects-tobacco-use/nicotine-why-tobacco-products-are-addictive)

---

WARNING: This product contains nicotine. Nicotine is an addictive chemical. For adults 21+ only. Stokes Picks are not a smoking-cessation product and are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.
